Depreciation recapture is one of the most misunderstood aspects of rental property taxation. When you sell a rental property, you must "recapture" (pay back) the depreciation deductions you claimed over the years at a 25% tax rate. This often catches investors off guard and significantly impacts their net proceeds from a sale.

⚠️ The Surprise Tax

Many investors focus solely on capital gains rates (0%, 15%, or 20%) but overlook depreciation recapture. For a property with $100,000 in accumulated depreciation, recapture tax alone is $25,000.

What is Depreciation Recapture?

Depreciation recapture is the IRS mechanism to "recoup" tax benefits you received from depreciation deductions during property ownership. It treats previously deducted depreciation as ordinary income (capped at 25%) rather than capital gains.

The Logic Behind Recapture

1. During Ownership

You deduct depreciation against ordinary income (potentially saving taxes at 37% rate)

→

2. At Sale

IRS recaptures those deductions at 25% rate (still beneficial overall)

💡 Key Insight

Even with recapture, depreciation usually provides net tax benefits because you get deductions at your marginal rate but pay recapture at the lower 25% rate.

How to Calculate Depreciation Recapture

Step-by-Step Calculation Process

1

Determine Total Depreciation Claimed

Add up all depreciation deductions taken over ownership period

Annual Depreciation × Years Owned = Total Depreciation
2

Calculate Adjusted Basis

Reduce original basis by total depreciation claimed

Adjusted Basis = Original Basis - Total Depreciation
3

Determine Gain Components

Split total gain between recapture and capital gains

Recapture = Min(Total Depreciation, Total Gain)
Capital Gain = Total Gain - Recapture
4

Apply Tax Rates

Calculate tax on each component

Recapture Tax = Recapture × 25%
Capital Gains Tax = Capital Gain × (0%, 15%, or 20%)

Tax Rates and Classifications

Section 1250 vs. Section 1245 Property

Section 1250 Property (Real Estate)

  • Includes: Buildings, improvements, residential/commercial structures
  • Recapture Rate: 25% maximum
  • Most Common: Rental properties, office buildings, warehouses

Section 1245 Property (Personal Property)

  • Includes: Equipment, fixtures, machinery, appliances
  • Recapture Rate: Ordinary income rates (up to 37%)
  • Examples: HVAC systems, carpeting, appliances

Tax Rate Summary

Income Component Tax Rate Notes
Section 1250 Recapture 25% Most rental property depreciation
Section 1245 Recapture Up to 37% Personal property/equipment
Capital Gains 0%, 15%, or 20% Based on income level
Net Investment Income Tax 3.8% High-income taxpayers

Real-World Examples

Example 1: Standard Recapture Scenario

Property Facts:

  • Purchase Price: $300,000
  • Building Value: $250,000 (depreciable)
  • Land Value: $50,000 (non-depreciable)
  • Ownership: 10 years
  • Annual Depreciation: $250,000 ÷ 27.5 = $9,091
  • Total Depreciation: $90,910
  • Sale Price: $450,000

Calculation:

Sale Price$450,000
Original Basis$300,000
Less: Depreciation Claimed($90,910)
Adjusted Basis$209,090
Total Gain$240,910
Gain Breakdown:
  • Depreciation Recapture: $90,910 (taxed at 25% = $22,728)
  • Capital Gain: $150,000 (taxed at 15% = $22,500)
  • Total Tax: $45,228

Example 2: Loss Scenario

What happens if you sell for less than original purchase price but more than adjusted basis?

  • Original Basis: $300,000
  • Depreciation Claimed: $90,910
  • Adjusted Basis: $209,090
  • Sale Price: $280,000

Result: Gain of $70,910 - ALL subject to depreciation recapture at 25% = $17,728 tax

Example 3: Massive Depreciation

Commercial property with substantial depreciation and improvements:

  • Original Basis: $1,000,000
  • Depreciation Claimed: $400,000
  • Sale Price: $1,200,000
  • Adjusted Basis: $600,000
  • Total Gain: $600,000

Tax Impact: $400,000 × 25% = $100,000 recapture tax alone!

Required vs. Actual Depreciation

One of the most important (and often misunderstood) aspects of recapture: you must recapture the greater of actual depreciation claimed OR allowable depreciation.

✅ If You Claimed Depreciation

Recapture the actual amount claimed on tax returns

⚠️ If You Forgot to Claim Depreciation

Still must recapture the allowable depreciation - as if you had claimed it

Forgotten Depreciation Example

Scenario: You owned a rental for 5 years but never claimed depreciation deductions

  • Allowable Annual Depreciation: $10,000
  • Total Allowable: $50,000
  • Actually Claimed: $0

Result: Must still recapture $50,000 at 25% rate, but you never got the tax benefit!

💡 Solution: Section 481(a) Adjustment

File Form 3115 to claim missed depreciation in the year of sale, then immediately recapture it. This ensures you get the tax benefit before paying recapture tax.

Timing and Payment

When Recapture Tax is Due

  • Recognition: Year of sale (like capital gains)
  • Payment: With tax return filing or estimated payments
  • No Deferral: Cannot be deferred like capital gains

Estimated Tax Considerations

📅 Quarter of Sale

Make estimated payment for quarter when sale occurs to avoid penalties

💰 Safe Harbor Rule

Pay 110% of prior year tax (100% if AGI < $150K) to avoid penalties

🏦 Withholding Alternative

Increase W-2 withholding or make quarterly payments to cover recapture tax

⚠️ Payment Planning

Recapture tax can be substantial. Set aside 25% of total accumulated depreciation from sale proceeds to avoid cash flow issues at tax time.

Legal Avoidance Strategies

1031 Like-Kind Exchange

🔄 The Complete Deferral

How it Works: Exchange your rental property for another investment property

Benefit: Defers BOTH capital gains and depreciation recapture

Requirements: Must be like-kind, investment/business use, strict timing rules

Result: Carries forward recapture liability to replacement property

Installment Sale Treatment

📅 Spread the Tax Burden

How it Works: Sell property with seller financing over multiple years

Limitation: Recapture tax is due in year of sale (cannot be spread)

Benefit: Capital gains portion can be spread over payment years

Opportunity Zone Investment

🏗️ Qualified Opportunity Zone Funds

How it Works: Invest capital gains (not recapture) in Opportunity Zone

Limitation: Only defers capital gains, not depreciation recapture

Timeline: Must invest within 180 days of sale

Charitable Remainder Trust

🎁 Philanthropic Strategy

How it Works: Transfer property to charitable trust, receive income stream

Benefit: Avoid immediate recapture, get charitable deduction

Consideration: Complex structure, requires philanthropic intent

Strategy Effectiveness Comparison

Strategy Capital Gains Depreciation Recapture Complexity
1031 Exchange ✅ Deferred ✅ Deferred Medium
Installment Sale ✅ Deferred ❌ Immediate Low
Opportunity Zone ✅ Deferred ❌ Immediate Medium
Charitable Trust ✅ Avoided ✅ Avoided High

Special Situations

Primary Residence Conversion

Scenario: Rental Converted to Primary Residence

If you convert rental property to primary residence and later sell:

  • Depreciation taken during rental period is still subject to recapture
  • Primary residence exemption applies only to gain after conversion
  • Cannot use $250K/$500K exclusion to offset depreciation recapture

Inherited Property

Step-Up Basis Impact

Inherited rental properties get special treatment:

  • Basis steps up to fair market value at death
  • Prior depreciation recapture potential is eliminated
  • Fresh start for depreciation calculations

Partnership/LLC Sales

Entity-Level Considerations

Sales by partnerships or LLCs:

  • Recapture passes through to individual partners/members
  • Each partner's share is based on ownership percentage
  • May trigger state tax consequences differently than capital gains

Tax Planning Tips

📊 Track Depreciation Carefully

  • Maintain detailed depreciation schedules
  • Separate building from land basis
  • Track improvement additions and their depreciation
  • Document cost segregation studies

💰 Cash Flow Planning

  • Set aside 25% of total depreciation taken
  • Make estimated tax payments quarterly
  • Consider withholding from other income sources
  • Plan for immediate recapture tax liability

⏰ Timing Strategies

  • Coordinate sale year with other income/deductions
  • Consider spreading gains via installment sales
  • Evaluate 1031 exchange opportunities
  • Time property improvements for maximum benefit

📋 Professional Consultation

  • Consult tax professional before major property sales
  • Model different scenarios and strategies
  • Consider state tax implications
  • Evaluate entity structure impacts

Year-End Planning Checklist

Key Takeaways

  • Depreciation recapture is taxed at a 25% rate on rental property sales
  • Must recapture the greater of actual or allowable depreciation
  • Recapture tax is due in the year of sale - cannot be deferred alone
  • 1031 exchanges can defer both capital gains and recapture
  • Primary residence exemption does NOT apply to depreciation recapture
  • Proper planning and record-keeping are essential for accurate calculations
  • Set aside 25% of accumulated depreciation for tax payments

Calculate Your Depreciation Recapture

Use our comprehensive capital gains calculator to determine your exact depreciation recapture tax liability before you sell.

Calculate My Tax Liability